| Spell | Ingredients | Original Good Result | Online Result | Original Backfire Result | Online Backfire Result | Tested Online |
| A friend indeed | butter + pet treats + clown confetti | Will turn a pet into a human. | | pets will get mad at you. | | |
| Banish | Butter + snake venom + garlic | Sends a sim into a black hole-like portal, from which they may never return. | | If used on a sim with wand, your sim will be banished instead. However, the sim does eventually return after a while. | | |
| Beauty or beast | Beeswax + beeswax + beeswax | Turns the caster into a mythical creature such as witch, genie, fairy, Frankenstein etc. | | turns you and people surrounding you into mules. Eventually wears off. | | |
| Clone drone | Beeswax + sands of time + Pegasus feather | Makes a clone of oneself. | | The clone may not do much, it might stand around, spill water everywhere, and explode where it will start a fire instantly. However, the clone can go to work for your Sim. | | |
| Dish wish | Golden thread + golden thread + llama spit | Cleans all fly-infested dishes. | Cleans all fly-infested dishes. | If you use this spell when you only have a few dishes it will make more appear. | If you use this spell when you only have a few dishes it will make more appear. | Yes |
| Enchant | Butter + toadstools + pixie dust | Enchants objects like gnomes, flamingos, and refrigerators. | Enchants objects like gnomes, flamingos, and refrigerators. | Sets what you were supposed to enchant on fire. | Sets what you were supposed to enchant on fire. | |
| Get happy | Honey + grapes + pixie dust | Improves a sim’s mood. | Improves a sim’s mood. | Can make the sim in an even worse mood. | Can make the sim in an even worse mood. | |
| Horn of plenty | Horn of plenty | Makes gourmet food appear. | Makes gourmet food appear. | If used by a greedy sim, a plague of toads will appear. | If used by a greedy sim, a plague of toads will appear. | |
| Hypnotize | Butter + toadsweat + clown confetti | Lets you control another sim. | Lets you control another players avatar | If they have a wand, they’ll hypnotize you. | If they have a wand, they’ll hypnotize you. | |
| Lovestruck | Honey + dragon tears + pixie dust | Makes a sim fall in love with you. | Makes a sim fall in love with you. | If the target has a wand, you get struck by lightning. | If the target has a wand, you get struck by lightning, and Die | |
| Magi mood | Beeswax + magic beans + Glacier glass | Maxes a sim’s mood (not usable on self). | Maxes a sim’s mood (not usable on self) | Head(s) turn into donkey heads. | Head(s) turn into donkey heads. | |
| Of house and home | Golden thread + glacial glass + Pegasus’ feather | Cleans and repairs everything. | Cleans and repairs everything. | Molly destroys everything in your home. | Molly destroys everything in your home. | |
| Perfect garden | Golden thread + magic beans + four leaf clover | Perfects your garden. | Perfects your garden. | Enchanted gnomes will attack and destroy your garden. | Enchanted gnomes will attack and destroy your garden. | |
| Polar attraction | Beeswax + dragon scales + llama spit | Makes a sim like you more. | Makes a random player like you more | | Makes a random player hate you more | |
| Rain of riches | Beeswax + rubber chicken + diamond dust | Treasure falls from the sky. | Treasure falls from the sky. | Storm clouds appear. | Bills you have to pay appear | |
| Relationship boost | Honey + honey + pixie dust | Increases relationship by 25 points. | Add 5 random players as friends | Decreases by 25 points. | Lose 10 Player friends | |
| Shed your skin | Beeswax + beeswax + sands of time | Turns caster into a ghost. | | Snakes appear; pet may turn into a snake. | | |
| Smiley face | Honey + garlic + toadsweat | Creates an instant friend. | | Sims become mad if already friends. | | No |
| The big question | dragon scales + clown confetti + wizard eyelashes | Proposes marriage. | | Relationship drops by 25 points. | | No |
| The price of fame | beeswax + diamond Dust + black roses | Turns a sim into a celebrity | Makes you become friend’s with 10 random players | 5 obsessed fans appear | | No |
| Toadification | Butter + toadstools + toad sweat | Turns a sim into a toad | Turns a sim into a toad | If target has a wand you become the toad | If target has a wand you become the toad | Yes |
